Garlic and magnetism

by Ed Sawicki - Fedruary 21, 2020

William Gilbert

William Gilbert

Spelling errors are plentiful on the Internet, but none have had the long-term impact as the one made by a Roman scribe in 75 AD.

In the late 16th century, a British physician named William Gilbert spent 18 years investigating all that was known about magnetism up to that point. Although he didn’t know it at the time, he was also investigating static electricity because he thought amber was magnetic since it attracted certain materials. He published his findings in a book called De Magnete. The 1900 English edition by Chiswick Press* is available (for free) at Project Gutenberg.

The book debunked some beliefs that had persisted for over 1500 years, mainly because the Church stifled scientific research a bit back then with threats of death. One such belief has to do with garlic. It was believed that garlic destroyed magnetic properties. Sailors were not allowed to chew garlic near a ship’s compass.

Gilbert traced the origin of the erroneous myth to a defective copy of a book written by Roman author Pliny the Elder in 75 AD or thereabouts. The scribe substituted the Latin word allio, meaning garlic for alio, which means “other”.

I came upon mention of this myth in the 2007 book Much Ado About Almost Nothing: Man's Encounter with the Electron written by Hans Camenzind.

* The title is "ON THE MAGNET, MAGNETICK BODIES ALSO, AND ON the great magnet the earth; a new Physiology, demonstrated by many arguments & experiments."

— END —